As nations address the problems surrounding individual security, there are four legal areas where new metrics could emerge to provide equitable access and appropriate treatment of individuals under a vertical regulatory framework. These are telecommunications, labor, antitrust, and national security.
Telecommunication regulation is critical to the first prong of an Equitable Network Standard because it influences equity in access to the global network. International connectivity metrics focus on subscriptions, coverage, and usage to determine the penetration of information and communication technology.[1] But the industry rewards average revenue per user, creating a tension between international goals to bring individuals online and the capital investment needed to survive in a competitive industry.[2] A telecommunication company is incentivized to target individuals that generate a higher average revenue and then entrench that individual with bundled services to lower churn rate and increase minutes used.[3] This results in the “Last Mile Problem” because the incremental costs to extend coverage exceeds the average revenue metric that the industry rewards.[4]
International metrics partly re-enforce the industry’s key performance indicators and “Last Mile Problem” because the United Nations’ International Telecommunication Union (ITU) focuses on the core indicators of access and usage but not necessarily quality of access.[5] Telecommunication companies need only meet and a nation need only require a de minimis standard to comply. However, the ITU has begun to shift to inclusive access to account for the opportunities that an individual has once initial access and usage exists.[6] This is encouraging for an adequate level of protection permitting individuals to fulfill their economic potential and benefit from the shared communities created in the digital space. To deliver on inclusive access, nations must adjust telecommunication regulation to account for equitable access at a minimum quality standard such that individuals may actively engage and belong globally. For example, a minimum quality standard could measure at network speed, consistency of connectivity, latency, packet loss, and random security penetration testing specifically for designated end-of-line zones and average household zones on a state by state basis.[7]
In tandem with inclusive access, labor law is critical to the second prong of an Equitable Network Standard because its influences appropriate treatment within the global network. Labor productivity metrics have focused on labor hours and increased consumption to determine productivity and standard of living.[8] But remote work, flexible schedules, and mass consumption challenge the sustainability of the current Gross Domestic Product approach. COVID undermined the ability to measure labor productivity because the pandemic dramatically shifted the workplace to remote access.[9] In turn, remote access adjusted the traditional workweek and workday.[10] Mass consumption, even before the supply chain pressures of COVID, presented a global threat because the environmental impact is proving unmanageable.[11] Nations can no longer focus the legal norms of labor to demand ever growing hours of productivity and consumption.[12]A new labor measurement that accounts for a minimum level of individual privacy for forming one’s desired quality of life is needed. One that provides for an adequate level of protection for an individual to fulfill their economic potential coinciding with a sustainable standard of living compatible with a mental health and individual formation . National labor laws must adjust to reflect new sustainable metrics and hold market actors accountable to meet this new form as an understood function within the marketplace.
Additionally, a nation must address market concentrations within its economy, especially for big data. Antitrust law is critical to the equitable access and appropriate treatment within a vertical framework because it defines consumer harm once within the global network. Antitrust law and consumer harm have fixated on ‘price’ as lowest monetary cost and languished in reevaluating ‘choice’, ‘deceptive practices’ and ‘predatory business practices’ in the era of big data. But intrusive advertising practices, barriers to exit, and social costs of micro-tracking have emerged as corrosive to individual security and political stability.[13] Market actors have used this gap to exploit digital privacy, entrench market share, and suppress competition. The exploitation of identity is most concerning as devices quietly gather data and sell those identities on ad exchanges.[14] And the societal harm is not only at the individual level.[15] The cumulative effect of these market behaviors threatens innovation by suppressing startups and future job creation.[16]
Similar to the Gilded Age, the Great Supply Chain Disruption revealed market concentrations in sectors from cars to semiconductors, toilet paper to baby formula.[17] Discerning metrics for antitrust is particularly difficult because regulations can bedevil governments with unintended negative effects on competition.[18] Nevertheless, antitrust law will need to reconcile new parameters on ‘price’, ‘choice’, ‘deceptive practices’ and ‘predatory business practices’.[19] Price can no longer be a race to a monetary low and uniformity, but instead must account for market quality and innovation. Choice must reflect portability opportunities whereby individuals control the movement of their identities across platforms and ad exchanges. Deceptive practices must account for misinformation and suppression. Finally, predatory business practices will need to expand to better identify, deter, and disrupt monopolies and duopolies that plaque supply chains across industry sectors.[20] Lastly, adequate mechanisms for enforcement must be developed that sufficiently protect individuals in the digital marketplace from the adverse effect of trading identity.
Finally, nations must address adequate protection of its citizens across the global network. National security law and data protection metrics are critical to equitable access and appropriate treatment delivering individual security because they create international alliances that protect individuals from nefarious actors across the global network. National security law and data protection metrics have struggled to establish secure infrastructure to protect selective privacy. But the exposure of zero-day software gaps, cyberwarfare on critical municipal services, and theft of commercial research threaten both individual and national well-being. Rogue actors and hostile nations repeatedly intrude into digital systems that host everything from clean water to text messages to health care systems.[21]
Data security can no longer afford to be responsive after harm occurs.[22] Instead a nation must implement a continuous best practice approach to provide the necessary protection of individual security for its citizens to thrive in the digital economy.[23] Accordingly, international bodies have begun to measure secure server access as a metric to determine the commitment a nation has to its cybersecurity within its vertical regulatory framework. Ideally, by providing adequate digital security, a nation will drive digital inclusion and enhance its position for overall development.
As regulatory goals emerge from data models and core values, measurement of the success of a vertical regulatory framework across telecommunication, labor, antitrust, and national security to value individual security is key. With such legal updates, the development of an international standard across the horizontal framework is better informed and protective of individuals, and in turn the overall system under which citizenship and formation is experienced. Just as the trade of manufactured goods thrived under Most Favored Nation and National Treatment, nations and international institutions must design and implement an equivalent norm for an Equitable Network Standard for the digital engagement in the global economy. Successful models exist. For example, as of 2022, 94 countries participate in the CISG to establish an international standard for transnational contracts. Whether handwritten or digital watermarked, the CISG sets a norm for those agreements that will cross international borders.[24]An Equitable Network Standard between nations could seek implementation through a similar instrument and encourage global best practices for individual security that insure equitable access to and appropriate treatment once within the global economy. It seems reasonable that if contractual agreements between entities is important enough for an international arrangement, then the individuals that such entities consist of and stand to benefit are also (if not more) critical to determine the international standard for adequate protection of those individuals.
[1] See https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/facts/default.aspx (last visited Apr 8, 2022).
[2] See https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/facts/default.aspx (last visited Apr 8, 2022); https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/122414/what-are-best-metrics-evaluate-telecommunication-company.asp (last visited Apr. 8, 2022).
[3] See https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/122414/what-are-best-metrics-evaluate-telecommunication-company.asp (last visited Apr. 8, 2022).
[4] See ITU Economic Experts Roundtable on the Telecommunication Industry in the post-COVID-19 world, Report of the 7th ITU Economic Experts Roundtable (2021) (www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Regulatory-Market/Pages/Events2020/EconomicRoundTable/home.aspx).
[5] See https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/coreindicators/default.aspx (last visited Apr. 8, 2022).
[6] See ITU Economic Experts Roundtable on the Telecommunication Industry in the post-COVID-19 world, Report of the 7th ITU Economic Experts Roundtable (2021) (www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Regulatory-Market/Pages/Events2020/EconomicRoundTable/home.aspx).
[7] See Federal Communications Commission, Measuring Fixed Broadband – Thirteenth Report, https://www.fcc.gov/reports-research/reports/measuring-broadband-america/measuring-fixed-broadband-thirteenth-report (Aug. 9, 2024). The FCC periodically measures some of this data, but agency modernization and federal incentives for states to compete on transparency of this data could make these metrics more robust. The addition of security penetration testing creates a public and transparent data point for states and companies to compete on the protection aspect of an adequate treatment.
[8] See https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/labor-productivity.asp (last visited Apr. 8, 2022).
[9] See https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/12/09/how-the-coronavirus-outbreak-has-and-hasnt-changed-the-way-americans-work/ (last visited May 10, 2022).
[10] See https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/12/09/how-the-coronavirus-outbreak-has-and-hasnt-changed-the-way-americans-work/ (last visited May 10, 2022).
[11] See Shi-Ling Hsu, Capitalism and the Environment: A Proposal to Save the Planet, 49 (Cambridge University Press, eds. 2021); Oliver C. Ruppel, Climate Change: International Law and Global Governance: Legal Responses and Global Responsibility 34 (Oliver C. Ruppel, et al. eds., 2013).
[12] See Frank J. Garcia, Convergences: A Prospectus for Justice in a Global Market Society, 29 Manchester Journal of International Economic Law 128, 131, 134 (2016).
[13] See Yan Lau, Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics, A Brief Primer on the Economics of Targeted Advertising 2, 9, 12 (Jan. 2020).
[14] See Yan Lau, Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics, A Brief Primer on the Economics of Targeted Advertising 4, 9, 11 (Jan. 2020).
[15] See Frank J. Garcia, Global Justice and International Law: Three Takes, 159-168 Cambridge University Press (2013).
[16] See Congressional Budget Office, Federal Policies in Response to Declining Entrepreneurship, 1 (Dec. 2020).
[17] See https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/01/business/supply-chain-disruption.html (last visited May 13, 2022); https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/13/briefing/baby-formula-shortage-us-economy.html (last visited May 13, 2022).
[18] See Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Guide for Helping Competition Authorities Assess the Expected Impact of Their Activities, 1 (Apr. 2014); Frank Pasquale and Jacqueline Green, Two Politicization of U.S. Antitrust Law, 15 Brook. J. Corp. Fin. & Com. L. 97, 129.
[19] See Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Factsheet on How Competition Policy Affects Macro-Economic Outcomes 2-4, 16-17 (Oct. 2014).
[20] See Kara Frederick, Combating Big Tech’s Totalitarianism: A Road Map, Backgrounder No. 3678, The Heritage Foundation (Feb. 7, 2022), 24, http://report.heritage.org/bg3678.
[21] See https://www.forbes.com/sites/jimmagill/2021/07/25/us-water-supply-system-being-targeted-by-cybercriminals/?sh=290024ce28e7 (last visited May 10, 2022); https://www.bostonglobe.com/2022/03/30/business/verizon-working-shut-down-scam-texting-campaign/ (last visited May 10, 2022); https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/27/world/europe/uk-ransomware-hack-north-korea.html (last visited May 10, 2022).
[22] See Internet Governance Forum, Katowice IGF Messages, Sixteenth Meeting of Internet Governance Forum 2-3, 6-7 (Dec. 6-10, 2021).
[23] See Internet Governance Forum, Katowice IGF Messages, Sixteenth Meeting of Internet Governance Forum 2-3, 6-7 (Dec. 6-10, 2021).
[24] See https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/salegoods/conventions/sale_of_goods/cisg/status (last visited Apr. 30, 2022).


