This insight explores the effects of information and communication innovations upon individual security, defined as the individual privacy to confidently form one’s identity, and in turn how nations may consider addressing those effects to deliver global justice. The terms discussed are broad and often polymorphic. As such, clarification on their meaning in the context of this piece is important.
Individual Security
Individual security refers to the ability to have the selective privacy to form an identity. Although security can refer to a range of areas from military to employment, here, the focus is not on such physical and external meanings. Instead, here, security derives from the mental and internal needs akin to a psychological development of a sense of self.[1] The fact that I do not discuss the other versions should not be read as implying their irrelevance; on the contrary, they are enormously important and often can impact internal and mental security. However, this narrower definition is necessary because of the novel way in which technology has tracked and monetized the private moments when individuals form their identity. By creating a trade in these identity formation decisions, confidence in having the secure privacy to form a sense of self is under pressure. This reflection focuses on rebalancing legal norms to better provide individuals with the privacy to confidently form a sense of self.
As individuals increase their connectivity to the global economy through adopting communication innovations, the protection of the selective privacy to form one’s identity becomes more critical. Selective privacy underpins an individual’s security because it permits an individual to control the exposure of their images, ideas, and values. In turn, an individual can select when and how to engage within a nation and beyond with ideas, images, and institutions. By protecting the privacy to determine timing, the individual is afforded the discretion to discern both what and how to contribute to a cultural consensus built within that nation. Such individual control is necessary to cultivate an individual personality and the values that then influence civic engagement and societal norms.[2] Confidence in controlling one’s selective privacy enables the formation of a secure and stable identity. Individual security invokes the Madisonian concept of respect for the pursuit of forming an such an identity and “diversity in the faculties of men, from which the rights of property originate”.[3] Sufficient privacy at self-determined times and duration creates a secure identity prepared to engage in citizenship and, subsequently, in the global economy.
Individual Identity
Individual identity is a polymorphic concept that includes a personalized identity and a global human identity. A personalized identity encompasses a sense of place and attachment via common descent, a community of customs, a community of beliefs, a sense of self, a shared history, and a shared language.[4] Personalized identity embraces the ability to have selective privacy to form customs, beliefs, and a sense of self before connecting to the global economy. Personalized identity relies on having individual security to control the timing and duration of selective privacy.
In contrast, a global human identity creates an awareness of connectivity and belonging.[5] Global identity embraces the ability for an individual to access and enter the global economy. This ability relies on having an understood level of protection surrounding one’s traditional identity once operating in the global network. An individual’s selective privacy and sense of community formulate a personalized identity. An individual then seeks the global identity’s sense of belonging within the global economy through that sense of self.
Consequently, individual identity encompasses the choices that one has made at both the global and personalized levels and that in turn enables one to operate within the global economy. Individual aspiration for both self-improvement and a better community drives participation in the global marketplace, but the ability to form such aspirations requires the respect and freedom to self-define those outcomes.[6]
This ability to form an individual identity is motivating the need to adjust vertical and horizontal regulatory frameworks because innovations in information technology and communications have eroded selective privacy. Individuals can no longer discern when, with whom, or how private details ranging from physical location to biometrics to family formation are shared.[7] Both state and non-state actors give only illusory promises that one’s digital search for information is private. Consequently, individual identity formation stunts from a lack of rigorous intellectual discernment in advance of actual action.[8] Just as fables and parables provide elements of right and wrong behaviors to compare the effects of one’s choices, sufficient safeguards to determine consequences before digital economic engagement must be provided. Nations and international institutions must restore sufficiency to the level of individual security that forming an identity relies on.[9]
Innovations in Information and Communication
Innovation in information and communication refers to the advancement in human connectivity with the rise of the internet, collection of data, and leap of telecommunications from wired to wireless. Advancements in how information travels across borders and within communities has compressed time, space, and individual privacy.[10] Private market actors have created nearly instantaneous and constantly demanding global data flows from exponentially more sources.[11] For example, through seeding surveys into social media networks, companies could rapidly gather data across multiple behaviors and create detailed records on individuals and their relationships.[12]
This compression of information’s time to market combined with expansive reach results in a dramatic increase in the exposure of an individual’s identity across the global network. Once an individual adopts internet and wireless telecommunications, connectivity dramatically increases well beyond pre-internet and pre-wireless social access.[13] These connections are subjected to what was once inappropriate, if not outright illegal, surveillance. This surveillance has transitioned into a movement to socially develop the global economy through data collection of personal activities, aspirations, and anxieties.[14] Simultaneously, an individual’s ability to preserve their selective privacy decreased as private actors increasingly monetize a global trade in identity. This juxtaposition of increased connectivity with less privacy presents a pressing challenge to protecting individual security.
The Vertical Regulatory Framework Within a Nation
A vertical regulatory framework refers to the normative legal system within a nation to address its political stability across its citizenship.[15] For example, the American Constitutional system features a fixed, written constitution that connects a federal government divided into legislative, executive, and judicial branches with a constellation of republican state governments. Featuring a democratic distribution of power, a normative legal adjustment across the system is feasible, but deliberately difficult. The structure requires widespread consideration across its citizenship. However, such a governmental structure retains its political stability across generations.
A more centralize governmental system – such as authoritarian– would instead enable substantive legal change in its regulations quickly, but intentionally does so without widespread consideration by citizens. In exchange for the speed of legal change, political stability is diminished across generations.
Regardless of a nation’s vertical regulatory structure, the system must offer an acceptable level of individual security to its citizenship such that the system cultivates a population willing to be governed. Without such a population, a nation is a legal fiction. This dependency on the existence of citizens makes sufficient privacy to form an individual identity a core principle underpinning international recognition. Additionally, that sufficient level must be sustained in the face of economic innovation. A nation’s vertical legal system that integrates the acceptable international norm obtains basic admission to the benefits of the digital economy as its societal and economic reward. By adjusting vertical regulations to account for individual security in response to changes in information and communication technology, a nation gains both economic benefits while enhancing political stability and preserving its national sovereignty. A nation demonstrates its commitment to sustainable engagement in the horizontal regulatory framework of the global economy through adequate protection of an individual’s ability to formulate an identity. Adequate protection is an internationally agreed upon Equitable Network Standard that a nation implements, monitors, and enforces though the values enacted in its vertical governmental framework. The stable existence and economic benefits as a functioning nation amongst the international institutions of the digital global economy acts as a positive incentive. In other words, demonstrate in pattern and practice the norm of the Equitable Network Standard, or risk ceding the ability to act and grow as a sovereign in the digital economy with one’s nation peers.
The Horizontal Regulatory Framework Between Nations
As such, the horizontal regulatory framework refers to international legal norms between nations that creates economic stability across the global economy, both in the real and digital worlds.[16] The pursuit of economic stability is a means by which the international system seeks to reinforce national political stability.[17] Although several viewpoints exist on economic diplomacy, the interlocking of nation states horizontally through trade often is considered a deterrent, hindering a nation from embarking on radical vertical regulatory adjustments that may violate international legal norms. [18]
Together, the vertical and horizontal regulatory frameworks construct a global legal regime that supports transactions between capital and individuals across the globe, forming an interconnected global economy. Global capital emerges, encapsulating everything from investments to solo practitioners to multi-nationals, because the individual security expectation set by the Equitable Network Standard acts as a foundation from which trust in transactions is restored. From this baseline, competition amongst nations to provide the most economically viable version of individual security – whether at or greater than the Equitable Network Standard norm – ensues. When the vertical and horizontal frameworks work in harmony, the resulting economic and political stability encourages capital and individuals to engage in that economy. The global flow of goods, services, labor, technology, and capital emerges because a baseline of adequate protection to the persons on each side of the digital exchange exists.[19] By building a global economy on a foundation of strong individual security, the network of global flows seeks to avoid larger social disruptions that would seriously undermine individual security.
Larger social disruption refers to inequitable resource allocation in the global network that erodes individual security by disrupting shared communities. The disruptions limit opportunities for selective privacy and in turn undermine the formation of a sense of self. By undermining confidence in forming an identity, the social contract strains within a nation, leading to domestic hostilities. Preventing hostilities is differentiated from normal faction within or between nations. Faction – a difference in individual identity – is necessary for innovation, capitalism, and freedom.[20] Instead, hostilities are disease, famine, oppression, and economic exploitation that often create the conditions for war, civil or international, as a distraction. Such social disruption breaks down vertical and horizontal regulatory frameworks as individuals react to inequitable resource allocation and a lack of agency to redress in such imbalances. Recent examples of these resource challenges can be seen in distribution of COVID vaccines and ‘end of line’ Internet access. In 2020, individuals from first and third world nations made the surprising discovery that they were joined in a global community of ‘have-nots’. The insufficient medical care and deficient digital connectivity for these unlikely allies exposed the lack of international norms to adequately address their individual identities, regardless of a nation’s wealth. In other words, existing metrics by which a nation is judged ‘wealthy’ faltered. As these accepted legal frameworks splinter and rupture from the social contract for their inadequacy towards a sufficient number of individuals within, a nation’s sovereignty comes under threat. Individuals ask: Why remain loyal when access to medical health for the body nor economic livelihood for the mind and soul is ensured by existing law? Consequently, the threat of social disruption motivates nations to repair social contracts and restore protection to individual security
However. as innovations in information and communication have intruded into individual security, the pressure of social disruption has built. This now calls into question how quickly global and national processes can provide redress before governments falter. In turn, a pivotal point has come for nations to improve their social contracts and deliver sufficient security for individuals to confidently access and engage in a just global economy.
[1] See Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow’s_hierarchy_of_needs (last visited Apr. 22, 2022).
[2] See ELena Boldyreva, Cambridge Analytica: Ethics and Online Manipulation with Decision-Making Process, 97 (May 2019).
[3] See James Madison, The Federalist Papers : No. 10 (1787); Frank J. Garcia, Convergences: A Prospectus for Justice in a Global Market Society, 13 Manchester Journal of International Economic Law 128, 129-30 (2016); Kara Frederick, Combating Big Tech’s Totalitarianism: A Road Map, Backgrounder No. 3678, The Heritage Foundation (Feb. 7, 2022), 24, http://report.heritage.org/bg3678.
[4] See Marilyn Cornelius and Thomas N. Robinson, Global identity and environmental sustainability: Related attitudes and actions 6 (2011) (unpublished manuscript) (on file with Precourt Energy Efficiency Center at Stanford University); Gerald Casper, The Concept of National Citizenship in the Contemporary World: Identity or Volition?, Bucerius Law School, 1 (2008).
[5] See Marilyn Cornelius and Thomas N. Robinson, Global identity and environmental sustainability: Related attitudes and actions 5 (2011) (unpublished manuscript) (on file with Precourt Energy Efficiency Center at Stanford University).
[6] See Frank J. Garcia, Convergences: A Prospectus for Justice in a Global Market Society, 10 Manchester Journal of International Economic Law 128, 143 (2016).
[7] See Texas Attorney General, Attorney General Ken Paxton Secures Historic $1.375 Billion Settlement with Google Related to Texans’ Data Privacy Rights (May 9, 2025), https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-secures-historic-1375-billion-settlement-google-related-texans-data.
[8] See Texas Attorney General, Attorney General Ken Paxton Secures Historic $1.375 Billion Settlement with Google Related to Texans’ Data Privacy Rights (May 9, 2025), https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-secures-historic-1375-billion-settlement-google-related-texans-data.
[9] See Frank J. Garcia, Convergences: A Prospectus for Justice in a Global Market Society, 10 Manchester Journal of International Economic Law 128, 129-30 (2016).
[10] See Marie McAuliffe and Binod Khadria, World Migration Report 2020 7-8 (2020).
[11] See Elena Boldyreva, Cambridge Analytica: Ethics and Online Manipulation with Decision-Making Process, 92 (May 2019).
[12] See Elena Boldyreva, Cambridge Analytica: Ethics and Online Manipulation with Decision-Making Process, 95-96 (May 2019).
[13] See Marie McAuliffe and Binod Khadria, World Migration Report 2020 7-8 (2020).
[14] See ELena Boldyreva, Cambridge Analytica: Ethics and Online Manipulation with Decision-Making Process, 96-98 (May 2019).
[15] See International Financial Organization, Bretton Woods Documents – Riddle Comments on Bretton Woods Proposals – Comments, 1849648, WB IBRD/IDA STAFF-09-02, World Bank Group Archives, Washington, D.C., United States.
[16] See International Financial Organization, Bretton Woods Documents – Riddle Comments on Bretton Woods Proposals – Comments, 1849648, WB IBRD/IDA STAFF-09-02, World Bank Group Archives, Washington, D.C., United States.
[17] See International Financial Organization, Bretton Woods Documents – Riddle Comments on Bretton Woods Proposals – Comments, 1849648, WB IBRD/IDA STAFF-09-02, World Bank Group Archives, Washington, D.C., United States.
[18] See International Financial Organization, Bretton Woods Documents – Riddle Comments on Bretton Woods Proposals – Comments, 1849648, WB IBRD/IDA STAFF-09-02, World Bank Group Archives, Washington, D.C., United States.
[19] See Frank J. Garcia, Introduction: Globalization, Power, States, and the Role of Law, 903, 906 Boston College Law Review (Oct. 12. 2012).
[20] See James Madison, The Federalist Papers : No. 10 (1787).


